What car insurance actually covers, and the gap most drivers miss

Why the cheapest quote can be the most expensive decision, and what to compare instead.

David Krug

By David Krug, Head of Content

Reviewed by Annie Membreve, Head of Quality Control

Updated · 10 min read

Fact-checked
6coverage types compared
12insurers reviewed
1gap to check first
In this guide

Two car insurance quotes can show nearly the same monthly price and cover very different things. The difference is usually in the limits, the deductible and the exclusions.

Before you compare premiums, compare what happens after a claim.

What the main coverages do

  • Liability pays for damage or injuries you cause to someone else.
  • Collision pays for damage to your car, minus the deductible.
  • Comprehensive covers theft, weather, fire and other non-collision damage.
  • Medical payments helps with medical bills for you and your passengers.

The coverage gap to check

Uninsured and underinsured motorist coverage is the gap drivers most often miss. It pays when the other driver cannot. Ask for the limits in writing, not just the label on the quote.

Ask this before you buy

What is my out-of-pocket cost after a total loss, and what is excluded from this policy?

How to compare quotes

Use the same coverage limits, deductibles and drivers for every quote. Then compare the annual premium, not the monthly payment. A low monthly price can hide a large down payment or a short policy term.

The right policy is the one that covers the loss you cannot afford to pay for yourself.

Common questions

Is the cheapest car insurance always the worst?

No. Price matters. But compare the limits, deductibles and exclusions before you decide.

Do I need uninsured motorist coverage?

In many states it is required or strongly recommended. It protects you when the other driver has no insurance or too little.

Sources

This guide draws on public data, accreditor directories and our own interviews.

  • Insurance Information Institute, auto insurance basics
  • National Association of Insurance Commissioners, consumer guides
Was this guide helpful?Your feedback shapes what we update next.
David Krug

About the author

David Krug

David leads the RaveReviews editorial team, turning research into clear comparisons and useful guides. He oversees content strategy, testing standards and the final read on every ranking.

Editorial standards·Contact the desk

Keep reading

More guides for the decision in front of you.

All guides
Insurance guideRenters insurance, explained: what it covers and what it doesn't6 min readRead the guide Education guideHow to choose an online college that employers actually respect12 min readRead the guide Money guideThe 50/30/20 budget is fine. Here's when to break it.8 min readRead the guide